Question?? Part 2......Rifle burst test

Talk about or share information about your centerfire rifles.
User avatar
Ray P
Senior Member
Posts: 645
Joined: Sat Dec 31, 2005 10:32 am
.204 Ruger Guns: 2-Rem 700 and Ruger#1 S/S
Location: NE Pa
Contact:

Question?? Part 2......Rifle burst test

Post by Ray P »

Who has the strongest action?? Wby......Savage.......Remington......Cooper...............Kimber......
Sako.........Ruger ?? There are some I missed!!
Most upper end hi-velocity cartridges have max chamber pressure of 65000psi...............so what are actions tested to? To be safe sided by the manufacture? Are we as consumers allowed to know this? Or ask this?
Just a question for thought.
Thanks and later. :huh:
Ray P
Last edited by Ray P on Thu Apr 14, 2011 5:56 am, edited 2 times in total.
Life is an adventure and often to short. Make the most with family and friends. Shoot often and shoot a small hole. Love the 204 Ruger!! NRA Life Member
"We are never to old to learn"
User avatar
Rick in Oregon
Moderator
Posts: 4942
Joined: Thu Dec 01, 2005 4:20 pm
.204 Ruger Guns: Sako 75V, Cooper MTV, Kimber 84M, Cust M700 11 Twist
Location: High Desert of Central Oregon
Contact:

Re: Question??

Post by Rick in Oregon »

Ray: All factories that produce rifles must first test them with "proof loads" that are loaded far over the normal working pressures for any SAMMI cartridge. As such, every rifle has been fired and stamped with the proof marks you see, proving they withstood this "proof" testing.

I worked for a rifle maker here for a while, and we tested action strength by blowing up a few nice actions using a .280 Rem case full of Bullseye. When you know where they break, you can then engineer the appropriate changes in regard to structural integrity. My wife regulary purchases proof loads for a well known rifle manufacturer, and they're not sold to anyone except industry makers that are SAMMI registered.

I doubt if you'll ever find out which action is the strongest....there's just no way to prove it one way or another without total destruction. :eew:

Note: Have you seen the current email set of photos circulating of the guy who blew up the Savage 110.....owww....his hand is hamburger! (Handloading error, no fault of the rifle)
Semper Fortis
Rick in Oregon
NRA Life/OHA/VHA/VVA

Oregon, East of the Cascades - Where Common Sense Still Prevails

Image
WaltherP99
Senior Member
Posts: 320
Joined: Tue May 06, 2008 4:54 pm
.204 Ruger Guns: Savage Model 12 VLP
Location: Berks County, Pennsylvania

Re: Question??

Post by WaltherP99 »

Rick in Oregon wrote:
Note: Have you seen the current email set of photos circulating of the guy who blew up the Savage 110.....owww....his hand is hamburger! (Handloading error, no fault of the rifle)
Wasn't it a ML?
User avatar
Rick in Oregon
Moderator
Posts: 4942
Joined: Thu Dec 01, 2005 4:20 pm
.204 Ruger Guns: Sako 75V, Cooper MTV, Kimber 84M, Cust M700 11 Twist
Location: High Desert of Central Oregon
Contact:

Re: Question??

Post by Rick in Oregon »

Why, yes it was.....burning SMOKELESS!
Semper Fortis
Rick in Oregon
NRA Life/OHA/VHA/VVA

Oregon, East of the Cascades - Where Common Sense Still Prevails

Image
User avatar
Glen
Moderator
Posts: 1741
Joined: Sun Feb 06, 2005 9:22 pm
.204 Ruger Guns: Rem700ADL
Location: New Philadelphia, Ohio
Contact:

Re: Question??

Post by Glen »

That Savage was built around smokeless powder. The problem was he overstoked it looking for more. I'm glad my adventurous side doesn't include 60,000+ pressures 3" from my face.
Friends Are Friends By Nature.

RIP Russ,Blaine, & Darrell!!

I don't like repeat offenders. I like DEAD offenders!!
Ted Nugent


Isn't there a minimum age for grampas??
^^^^^^
Audrey Renae told me "No there isn't"!!

Glen
WaltherP99
Senior Member
Posts: 320
Joined: Tue May 06, 2008 4:54 pm
.204 Ruger Guns: Savage Model 12 VLP
Location: Berks County, Pennsylvania

Re: Question??

Post by WaltherP99 »

:eek: :eek: :eek:

I've seen pics of the rifle but not of his hand.....

HEARD it isn't to nice looking...
User avatar
Glen
Moderator
Posts: 1741
Joined: Sun Feb 06, 2005 9:22 pm
.204 Ruger Guns: Rem700ADL
Location: New Philadelphia, Ohio
Contact:

Re: Question??

Post by Glen »

No it wasn't. I hope he got some use back in it.
Friends Are Friends By Nature.

RIP Russ,Blaine, & Darrell!!

I don't like repeat offenders. I like DEAD offenders!!
Ted Nugent


Isn't there a minimum age for grampas??
^^^^^^
Audrey Renae told me "No there isn't"!!

Glen
User avatar
Ray P
Senior Member
Posts: 645
Joined: Sat Dec 31, 2005 10:32 am
.204 Ruger Guns: 2-Rem 700 and Ruger#1 S/S
Location: NE Pa
Contact:

Re: Question??

Post by Ray P »

Thanks for the replys Guys!! Nope didn't see any pics of the Savage 110 with a stiff charge or the gus hand.
Had a guy here in Pa that was working on a 408 chy-tek. Have someone building the action for him!! He was test loads..........and ...........IT let go................He's alive I heard, his right hand is messed up. Launch a Nightforce scope thru the roof of his shooting room..................ouch !
Later............and Happy Easter to all!
Ray P
Life is an adventure and often to short. Make the most with family and friends. Shoot often and shoot a small hole. Love the 204 Ruger!! NRA Life Member
"We are never to old to learn"
WaltherP99
Senior Member
Posts: 320
Joined: Tue May 06, 2008 4:54 pm
.204 Ruger Guns: Savage Model 12 VLP
Location: Berks County, Pennsylvania

Re: Question??

Post by WaltherP99 »

Ray: It was the guy from MCR was it?
User avatar
Ray P
Senior Member
Posts: 645
Joined: Sat Dec 31, 2005 10:32 am
.204 Ruger Guns: 2-Rem 700 and Ruger#1 S/S
Location: NE Pa
Contact:

Re: Question?? Part 2 ??

Post by Ray P »

Ok I appreciate the replys and input.
I Have a 2nd ?..............On bolt actions are the bolts and recivers the same hardness? Or is one harder than the other!
Do manufactures harden the hole bolt or just harden the lugs?
Thanks for any info or help.
Later
Ray P
Life is an adventure and often to short. Make the most with family and friends. Shoot often and shoot a small hole. Love the 204 Ruger!! NRA Life Member
"We are never to old to learn"
User avatar
Ray P
Senior Member
Posts: 645
Joined: Sat Dec 31, 2005 10:32 am
.204 Ruger Guns: 2-Rem 700 and Ruger#1 S/S
Location: NE Pa
Contact:

Re: Question?? Part 2........Rifle burst test

Post by Ray P »

I found this clip over on Long Range Hunting web site.........

Re: Rifle burst tests, how good is your rifle?
Back in the late sixties a gun magazine ran a test on five rifles with overloaded
rounds. The Win, Rem, and Browning (FN Mauser back then) all blew on the first
round, the Weatherby went three, the Ruger stood five and was still intact, at that
point they quit shooting it. Not really pertinent to todays guns but interesting.
Later
Ray P
Life is an adventure and often to short. Make the most with family and friends. Shoot often and shoot a small hole. Love the 204 Ruger!! NRA Life Member
"We are never to old to learn"
okbob51
New Member
Posts: 17
Joined: Fri Jul 24, 2009 6:02 am
.204 Ruger Guns: Cooper

Re: Question?? Part 2........Rifle burst test

Post by okbob51 »

Ray P wrote:I found this clip over on Long Range Hunting web site.........

Re: Rifle burst tests, how good is your rifle?
Back in the late sixties a gun magazine ran a test on five rifles with overloaded
rounds. The Win, Rem, and Browning (FN Mauser back then) all blew on the first
round, the Weatherby went three, the Ruger stood five and was still intact, at that
point they quit shooting it. Not really pertinent to todays guns but interesting.
Later
Ray P
I think I remember that test. I think Ruger used the results in some way to advertise the strength of their castings. I usually load right around max. loads and it's nice to know the guns will take it some a little extra.
Post Reply