Page 1 of 2

Mystery ?

Posted: Sun Nov 25, 2007 10:17 am
by adam
Image
This is my first attempt at putting pics up on here so bear with me :!:
If this shows up its a shot at a rabbit I took a while back. The point of interest is that I could not find any evidence of an entry or exit hole anywhere on it !!!
However it was knocked down stone dead and had a broken back and a broken front leg. Has anyone experienced this kind of thing before?
I can only think that the bullet must have literally just skimmed over him and the shock or preasure broke its bones.

Re: Mystery ?

Posted: Sun Nov 25, 2007 2:54 pm
by foxwhistler
What sort of range did you take the shot,and what ammo did you use?
I remember a couple of months ago someone posted on exactly the same subject,but unfortunatly i cant find the post at the moment.Perhaps someone else will come in and point you in the right direction.
Jamie.
Just found out the post was called .204 bullet failure.
Hope this helps.

Re: Mystery ?

Posted: Mon Nov 26, 2007 10:59 am
by adam
It was 300yds with rem accutip factory ammo in 40grain

Re: Mystery ?

Posted: Mon Nov 26, 2007 11:12 am
by bullfrog
At that range could the bullet have been a little low, and then gravel or shrapnel from the bullet hitting the ground my have knocked the little bugger silly?
Just a thought.
:duh:

Re: Mystery ?

Posted: Mon Nov 26, 2007 1:02 pm
by adam
I dont know but I have been thinking, and I remember that when I hit the rabbit, or thought I'd hit it, it made that familliar 'whop' sound like bursting a wet paper bag if you get what I mean!!!
Work that out!! :? :?

Re: Mystery ?

Posted: Mon Nov 26, 2007 2:19 pm
by foxwhistler
The longest shot ive actually connected with on a rabbit is 345 yards,and you could definatly see the entrance on that.Huge hole in the shoulder,and that was with a 40 grain V-max.
I think i`ll have to give up on this as the more i think about it,the more im confusing myself.Id like to know the answer though.
On a side note,where are you in carmarthenshire,as im only down the road in llandysul.
Jamie.

Re: Mystery ?

Posted: Tue Nov 27, 2007 12:55 pm
by adam
I have shot plenty more at ranges like these and my furthest being 370yds. Most of them i have hit and the wound is large and they are killed instantly. However this business of no entry or exit has happened twice before again with the rabbits having one or several broken limbs!!!
foxwhistler: I'm living about 4 miles llanelli side of carmarthen. What set up you shooting? :D

Re: Mystery ?

Posted: Tue Nov 27, 2007 1:25 pm
by foxwhistler
Just wondering if you have taken the skin off one of these rabbits,and if so,what was the internal damage like?
I`m shooting a Remington L.V.S.F with a leupold 4.5-14x50 long range,and a reflex moderator.
At the moment i`m using 32grain V-max handloads,that are shooting .7 of an inch.Plenty good enough for fox.
As soon as the woodcock season finishes i`m hoping to try some 39grain Sierra`s+35 bergers,but at the moment i just havent got time.
Jamie.

Re: Mystery ?

Posted: Tue Nov 27, 2007 1:30 pm
by adam
No I have'nt skinned them. Wish I had now! But I can say that the one of the rabbits this happened to had a broken back and I could hear a lot of jelly like sound inside when I shook it.
Do you know Lloyd at Lampeter gun shop?
Where you working?
adam

Re: Mystery ?

Posted: Tue Nov 27, 2007 1:39 pm
by foxwhistler
I know Lloyd very well.Just hope he never tells the wife how much money i`ve spent in his gun shop over the years.Think that would probably be grounds for divorce.
I work in the abbatoir in llanybyther.

Re: Mystery ?

Posted: Mon Dec 03, 2007 8:26 pm
by nzs204
I started a thred awhile back called ".204 bullet failure" if anyone wants to look at it.
I had the same experience with my .204 with factory hornady vmax loads but from much closer range.

I shot a rabbit, from approx 100meters, with i THINK it was 32gr vmax, (although it also could have been a 40gr vmax) , either way it was hornady vmax factory ammo...I shot the rabbit, square in the side as far as i could tell, i put the crosshairs on the rabbit, pulled the trigger, it flopped over instantly, although apon inspection there was no damage at all. No entry, no exit, nothing...just a stone dead rabbit...I still dont know what happened with that particular shot but it is the only rabbit i have ever shot with my .204 that has not been literally inside out...
So you aint the only one who has experienced the magical no damage instant kill .204 round! :roll:

Re: Mystery ?

Posted: Mon Dec 03, 2007 10:50 pm
by savage rookie
not to be gross...

Image

this was a rabbit shot at 412 yards with a 40g vmax, IMVUO (In My Very Uneducated Opinion)it must have been shockwaves or simplly fear that killed the rabbit. I can't see anyway that a projectile travelling at that speed could not have left a mark.

then again I could just be talking out my butt as I just got home from bowling league....

SR

Re: Mystery ?

Posted: Mon Dec 03, 2007 10:55 pm
by Glen
Shot in the ear?? :shrug:

Re: Mystery ?

Posted: Tue Dec 04, 2007 5:35 am
by sniper model 12
Glen wrote:Shot in the ear?? :shrug:
I have shot ground hogs in the ear before. . . from as close as 6 feet away to 175 yds. BUT
there was an exit hole like you wouldn't believe.

I think creekwalkr has some pics of his ghog shot at 6ft. Massive damage!! He was using a 40 gr vmax.

Re: Mystery ?

Posted: Tue Dec 04, 2007 6:46 pm
by finman
Hi Adam,

the most likely explanation is that the bullet hit the rabbit but did not fragment. Hence it went through the length of the critter (busting bones on the way) and even exited, but leaving a very small hole that you would not notice unless you skinned the animal.

I have had the same experience when shooting rabbits with the .17HMR and, at the beginning I thought I scared them to death, but when I skinned them they were an absolute mess, inside, with the outside having just 2 barely perceptible holes (which you could only observe from the non-hairy side of the hide).

I hope this helps .

Best wishes,


Finman