257 Weatherby for mule deer, 100 or 120 gr?

Talk about North American big game hunting.
RLKondo
New Member
Posts: 29
Joined: Sun Apr 06, 2008 5:46 pm
.204 Ruger Guns: NEF 204
Location: Central Washington

257 Weatherby for mule deer, 100 or 120 gr?

Post by RLKondo »

Hello All,

I just went out and baught a 257 weatherby because I found a great deal and because I have a late season deer hunt coming up. Nothing like a great excuse to buy another gun!

1st question- Will 100 gr bullet be enough for a large mule deer, lets say out to 300 yards or should I move to 120 gr?

Is there much of a difference between the 2, will the deer know the difference?

2nd, If i am hunting in a very windy area, should I scrap the 257 and use a 300 - 180 gr

This of course assuming that I do my part shooting and have proper bullet placement.

What other loads are you guys using with the 257 or 25-06 for big game?

Thanks!!!
User avatar
Rick in Oregon
Moderator
Posts: 4942
Joined: Thu Dec 01, 2005 4:20 pm
.204 Ruger Guns: Sako 75V, Cooper MTV, Kimber 84M, Cust M700 11 Twist
Location: High Desert of Central Oregon
Contact:

Re: 257 Weatherby for mule deer, 100 or 120 gr?

Post by Rick in Oregon »

RL: Your 257Wby will be at its best for mulies with the 120gr bullet. If you want to go lighter, the Barnes Tipped Tripple Shock would be very good too. But you'll want the heavier bullet to better buck the always present breeze, so I'd go with the 120gr, as you've certainly got the boiler room to give very good velocities and flat trajectory.

If it's windy enough to consider leaving your 257Wby in camp and taking your '06 out with 180's, it's probably too windy to hunt/shoot anyway. Take your 257 with 120's and complete confidence. :D

(I've been killing mulies with my 270Win and 130's now almost every year since 1968.)
Semper Fortis
Rick in Oregon
NRA Life/OHA/VHA/VVA

Oregon, East of the Cascades - Where Common Sense Still Prevails

Image
RLKondo
New Member
Posts: 29
Joined: Sun Apr 06, 2008 5:46 pm
.204 Ruger Guns: NEF 204
Location: Central Washington

Re: 257 Weatherby for mule deer, 100 or 120 gr?

Post by RLKondo »

RIO,

Thanks for the quick reply, great information as always! I am headed to Cabelas this after noon to bight the bullet and buy a box of shells, because Im not going to have time to reload. :mad:

I hope I have great pictures to show after the hung.

Thanks again, any other 257 weatherby info you guys can provide, will be gladly accepted


Enjoy the best holiday season of the year - Hunting!
Bill K
Senior Member
Posts: 2324
Joined: Tue Jan 18, 2011 10:00 am
.204 Ruger Guns: also now, a Savage switch bull barrel in 204R. 23 inch SS
Location: Lake Forest, Ca.

Re: 257 Weatherby for mule deer, 100 or 120 gr?

Post by Bill K »

I have always preferred the old standby, 120 grain Nosler partition.. Works just great in any of my 25's on deer or elk. And a bear or two. :) Bill K :)
Guy M
Senior Member
Posts: 405
Joined: Sun Mar 11, 2007 11:58 am
Location: Washington state

Re: 257 Weatherby for mule deer, 100 or 120 gr?

Post by Guy M »

I've had excellent results on mule deer with the 115 gr Nosler Ballistic Tip at 3120 fps mv from my .25-06 rifle. Accurate and very deadly. Also penetrates much better than many might anticipate - as in completely through the buck and instant drops.

We've got a .257 Weatherby here at the house too, but haven't used it a lot lately. Older gun that my son is trying to bring back to life. I think he's going to ask me to have it re-barreled for his birthday or something... It really could stand a new barrel, so my handload & hunting info for it isn't strong. It is however much like my .25-06, with another 100 - 200 fps on tap.

Guy
Post Reply